The Hindenburg Hydrogen Fire: Fatal Flaws in the Addison Bain Incendiary-Paint Theory
نویسنده
چکیده
A theory of the Hindenburg fire that has recently gained popular acceptance proposes that the paint on the outer surface of the airship caused both the fire and its rapid spread. However, application of physical laws and numerical calculations demonstrate that the theory contains egregious errors. Specifically: (1) The proposed ignition source (an electrical spark) does not have sufficient energy to ignite the paint. (2) The spark cannot jump in the direction demanded by the theory. If a spark were to occur, it could jump only in the direction that the author of the theory has shown will not cause a fire. (3) The most obvious flaw in the theory is the burn rate of the paint, which, in the theory, is likened to solid rocket fuel. The composition of the paint is known, and it is not a form of solid rocket fuel. Even if it were, it would, at best, burn about 1,000 times too slowly to account for the rapid spread of the fire. For example, if the Hindenburg were coated with exactly the same solid rocket fuel as that used in the Space Shuttle solid rocket boosters, it would take about 10 hours for the airship to burn from end to end, as compared to the actual time of 34 seconds. The arguments and calculations in this paper show that the proposed incendiary paint theory is without merit.
منابع مشابه
The Hindenburg Fire : Hydrogen or Incendiary Paint ?
A theory of the Hindenburg fire that has gained popular acceptance proposes that an incendiary paint covered the outer surface of the airship. Further, according to this theory, the paint was both the point of ignition and the sole cause of the rapid spread of the fire. The hydrogen within the airship is held blameless for both the start of the fire and its subsequent advance. We have examined ...
متن کاملHydrogen and Helium
The giant dirigible hovers near the mooring mast and drops its landing lines to the crew on the ground. Suddenly, a sheet of fire bursts from its tail. Within minutes, the 800-ft-long craft is reduced to a tangled mass of charred wreckage; 35 people are dead, and dozens are injured. The accident is famous: the spectacular explosion of the German dirigible, Hindenburg. Less well known, however, ...
متن کاملThe net benefits of human-ignited wildfire forecasting: the case of Tribal land units in the United States.
Research shows that some categories of human-ignited wildfires might be forecastable, due to their temporal clustering, with the possibility that resources could be pre-deployed to help reduce the incidence of such wildfires. We estimated several kinds of incendiary and other human-ignited wildfire forecast models at the weekly time step for tribal land units in the United States, evaluating th...
متن کاملArson: a diagnostic study.
Arson is a socially costly, complex, and little-studied phenomenon in America. Fire setting, or incendiarism, is on the increase, and it costs America billions of dollars and an estimated 1,000 deaths and 10,000 injuries annually. In 1978 there were a reported 557,000 structural and vehicle fires of incendiary or suspicious origin, costing over a billion dollars. If one considers half the unkno...
متن کاملUsing Numerical Simulation to Test the Validity of Neo-Darwinian Theory
Evolutionary genetic theory has a series of apparent “fatal flaws” which are well known to population geneticists, but which have not been effectively communicated to other scientists or the public. These fatal flaws have been recognized by leaders in the field for many decades—based upon logic and mathematical formulations. However population geneticists have generally been very reluctant to o...
متن کامل